Regulatory Framework for Legislative Drafting in Pakistan: Challenges and a Way Forward

Authors

  • Malik Junaid Arshad Ph.D. Law (Scholar), Department of Law, Bahria University Islamabad, Pakistan
  • Dr. Tauseef Iqbal Department of Law, Bahria University, Islamabad Pakistan

Keywords:

Legislative Drafting, Regulatory Framework for Legislative Drafting, Turning Policy into Legislation

Abstract

It is widely accepted that the regulatory framework for legislative drafting addresses many legal challenges, including turning policy into legislation, the intelligibility of legislative expression, interpretation of statutes, and the rule of law. It leads the administration of justice towards achieving desired policy objectives. Without a predictable legislative drafting regulatory framework, the drafting quality causes failure to achieve desired policy objective, lack of rule of law, ambiguity, unintelligibility, and unpredictability of legislation. However, it is equally true that many of these challenges are prevalent to a large extent in Pakistan. The deficiency of legislative drafting regulatory practices, expertise, and deficient legislative expression impedes the enforcement of laws and administration of justice in Pakistan. It is quite apparent that the legislative drafting problems faced in the heterogeneous society of Pakistan appear to be more critical than any other larger county. The article exposes the necessity for Pakistan to adopt, special procedures, policies, and infrastructure based on internationally recognized principles of legislative drafting for intelligible, clear, and predictable legislation.

Author Biographies

Malik Junaid Arshad , Ph.D. Law (Scholar), Department of Law, Bahria University Islamabad, Pakistan

Ph.D. Law (Scholar), Department of Law,

Dr. Tauseef Iqbal , Department of Law, Bahria University, Islamabad Pakistan

Senior Assistant Professor

References

(OECD), O. f.-o. (2019, 08 02). Good Governance in Egypt Legislative Drafting Manual for Better Policy. Paris, France: OECD.

Ahmed, S. S. (2019). Legislative Drafting Manual. Islamabad: Pakistan Institute for Parliamentary Services.

Ahmed, S. S. (2019). Legislative Drafting Manual A Handbook for Legislative Drafters. Islamabad: Pakistan Institute of Parliamentary Services.

Bentham, J. (1823). An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation, Volume 1. W. Pickering.

Bentham, J. (1891). Theory of Legislation (Vol. 7). (R. Hildreth, Trans.) K. Paul, Trench, Trübner. Retrieved from https://books.google.com.pk/books?id=Lbb05L0NYkUC&dq=Theory+of+Legislation&source=gbs_navlinks_s

Biribonwoha, P. P., & Biribonwoha, P. P. (2006). The Role of Legislative Drafting in the Law Reform Process. 32(4), 601-608.

Boeckenfoerde, D. (2006). Manual on Legislative Drafting. Max Plank Manual on Legislative Drafting on the National Level in Sudan. Heidelberg: Max Plank Institute of Comparative Public Law and International Law.

Bungham, T. (2011). The Rule of Law. UK: Penguin.

Coremacain, R. (2017). Legislative Drafting and the Rule of Law. London: Institute of Advance Legal Studies, University of London.

Crabbe, V. C. (1993). Legislative Drafting. UK: Routledge.

Department, L. (2014). D.O No. 11 (35)/ 2013-LI, 5 FEB 2013 Ministry of law and Justice 2013, Legislative Department, Government of India. Pre-Legislative Policy. India: Ministry of Law and Justice.

Dickerson, F. R. (1977). Legislative Drafting. Greenwood Press.

Dickerson, R. (1955). How to Write a Law. Notre Dame Law Review, 14-27.

Good Law Making Practice and Legislative Drafting Conforming to It in the Republic of Estonia. (2004). Juridicat international, IX, 4-13.

Hiranandani, S. (1964). Legislative Drafting: An Indian View. The Modern Law Review, 1-8.

Hiranandani, S. K. (1964). Legislative Drafting: An Indian View. The Modern Law Review, Vol. 27, 1-8.

Hiranandani, S. K. (1964). Legislative Drafting: An Indian View. The Modern Law Review, 27(1), 1-8.

Jaja, T. C. (2012). Legislative Drafting: An Introduction to Theories and Principles. Wolf Legal Publishers.

Narits, R. (2004). Good Law Making Practice and Legislative Drafting Conforming to it in the Republic of Estonia. Juridica International, 4-13.

Oigusloome, K. T. (2000). Legislative Drafting, Nature and Problems of Regulatory Practice. Estonia.

Pakistan, M. (2017). Manual for Legislative Drafting. Manual for Legislative Drafting, A Primary Guide for Legislation Drafters. Islamabad, Pakistan: Manzil Pakistan.

Pakistan, M. (2017). Manual for Legislative Drafting-A Primary Guide for Legislative Drafters. Manzil Pakistan.

Sector for Strategic Planning, A. C. (2014). Report on the Implementation of the Uniform Rules for Legislative Drafting in the Institutions of Bosnia and Herzegovina. Sarajevo: Official Gazette of BiH.

Seidman, A., Seidman, R., & Abeyesekere, N. (2001). Legislative Drafting for Democratic Social Change. South Holland: Kluwer Law International B.V.

Senate, M. (2003). Legislative Drafting Manual. Legislative Drafting and Legal Manual (3 ed. 2003). Boston, Massachusetts, United StATES: Massachusetts Senate.

Stefanou, C., & Xanthaki, H. (2016). Drafting Legislation: A Modern Approach. Routledge.

Thornton, G. C. (1996). Legislative Drafting. Bloomsbury Academic.

Thoronton, G. C. (1996). Legislative Drafting. London: Bloomsbury Academic.

Xanthaki, H. (2013). Legislative drafting: a new sub-discipline of law is born. IAS Student Law Review, 1(1), 57-70.

Xanthaki, H. (2013). Legislative Drafting: a New Sub-Discipline of Law is Born. IAS Student Law Review, 57-70.

Xanthaki, H. (2013). Thornton's Legislative Drafting. Bloomsbury Academic.

Xanthaki, H. (2014). Drafting Legislation: Art and Technology of Rules for Regulation. Hart Publishing.

Xanthaki, H. (2014). Drafting Legislation: Art and Technology of Rules for Regulation. Hart Publishing.

Zamboni, M. (2018). Legislative Policy and Effectiveness: A (Small) Contribution from Legal Theory. European Journal of Risk Regulation, 416-430.

Downloads

Published

2021-06-30

How to Cite

Arshad , M. J. ., & Iqbal , D. T. . (2021). Regulatory Framework for Legislative Drafting in Pakistan: Challenges and a Way Forward. Pakistan Journal of Languages and Translation Studies, 9(1), 34–52. Retrieved from https://pjlts.uog.edu.pk/index.php/pjlts/article/view/5